“If you got biochar, I feel bad for you, son.
I got ninety-nine problems but nitrates ain’t one.”
– Concerned Hydroponicist

biocharWhat is biochar?

Biochar is charcoal- specifically, it’s charcoal created from plant matter.

It’s a great option as a sustainable nutrient-stabilizing practice…. just not for hydroponics or aquaponics.

I’m going to tell you why biochar is terrible, awful, no-good, very bad idea for use in hydroponic or aquaponic systems.

Biochar retains nitrogen

Biochar possesses many beneficial traits which can contribute a lot to sustainable, earth-healthy practices.

Unfortunately, the same thing that makes biochar the star-child of various agricultural and environmental agencies is a death sentence for hydroponic and aquaponic systems.

That trait is nitrogen retention.

In ecosystems that experience rapid or “flash” movement of nutrients (like parts of the Amazon, which as it so happens is where the use of biochar originated), biochar can be mixed with soil to capture some of those nutrients as they move through the soil.

In that form, the nutrients – namely, nitrogen –  are released and available to plants in the long term.

Dr. Nate Storey“What people don’t understand is that it works in tropical soils because it’s mixed with fat, with waste from the camp, with garbage, and it manages to hold on because it’s got high cation exchange capacity. It holds on to those nutrient well and it keeps them from from dissolving in solution and washing away. So in the tropics, in the amazon, where 90% of all of the nutrition is tied up in the actual plants, almost none of it is in the soil because it just washes away if it’s in the soil-  then yeah, organic matter does a great job of tying up nutrients and making them available.”

Why Biochar + Hydroponics = A Terrible, Awful, No-good, Very Bad Idea

Use biochar in hydroponics, on the other hand, and all hell breaks loose.

As Dr. Nate explains…

“You get a bunch of people who take it and dump it into their systems that they’ve been working on; they’ve been adding compost, they’ve been fertilizing. Then they dump biochar in, and it crashes their nitrogen, because the microbes start to break down that carbon and to do that they consume nitrogen. They consume nitrogen to break down the carbon, and it’s not carbon that’s going to the plants.”

A few weeks ago we got a call from a befuddled aquaponicist, with a good stocking density and a cycled system but no nitrates showing on test measurements.

After learning more about the system we discovered that in addition to her ZipGrow towers, she had a media bed filled with biochar as recommended by a friend. As her fish produced ammonia, her microbes converted it to nitrates, and the copious volume of biochar sucked up her nitrates so fast that even Pacman would be green with envy. Her plants, unfortunately, did not share that healthy hue- now deficient in a primary nutrient, they were stunted and slow-growing.

Not only is biochar detrimental to aquaponics and hydroponics, it is completely unnecessary by any string of logic.

Most hydroponic systems, and all aquaponic systems, are recirculated. (If your system is not recirculated, it should be.) Your nutrients have only one place to go: to your plants. You don’t need to worry about tying them up in organic matter for long-term use.

People usually use biochar on a bad recommendation or with the logic that if it works in one place then it will work in another.

This “one size fits all” mentality is pretty common in alternative agriculture. In fact, when I asked Dr. Nate a few weeks ago about the worst aquaponics advice he had ever heard, he replied, “People are always recommending you add biochar. That’s terrible advice.”

Replace biochar with an inert media

ZipGrow Matrix MediaSo if you are using biochar in your system, it’s time to take it out.

You’ll be delighted with the change in your nitrification.

If you have to replace biochar with another type of media, use an inert media such as Matrix Media.